The ongoing
Bexit negotiations led by Theresa May hold valuable lessons for future
negotiations, mostly on how not to do it.
During her
time as home secretary she made a name for herself as a prudent and competent
operator. Even though she campaigned for the UK to remain within the European
Union, surely she would be savvy enough get a good Brexit deal approved by
parliament.
Mrs. May entered
the negotiations overconfident, mistakenly thinking that the UK was in the
stronger negotiations position and drawing red lines that were in her mind non-negotiables.
As a Brexit
secretary she chose David Davis, for no other apparent reason than that he was
one of the strongest Brexit supporters. But he resigned after only a year in
the job, which he never seemed to take seriously in the first place. But he was
not the only one to resign from team May – she has had 37 ministers resign (and
counting). That is more than any other UK Prime Minister has ever had.
Mrs May
stuck to her lines and was uncompromising in her approach. She came up with one
deal, that was voted on by the members of parliament a few times, and every
time defeated by record margins. Even some of her own executives voted against
her. Predictably, she ran out of time, and had to go and beg for more time from
the increasingly impatient EU.
So, what
can we learn about her disastrous negotiation skills?
Firstly,
don’t start the countdown until you have a comprehensive plan. It was up to the
UK’S Prime Minister to start the two-year period by triggering article 50. When
the UK Brexit negotiators met the European negotiators for the first time, they
seemed woefully underprepared. If one has the ability to start the clock, make
sure you know exactly what you want to achieve in that time period, with
different options at hand should the negotiations become deadlocked.
Secondly,
make sure that your whole team sings from the same hymn sheet. As the Prime Minister
lay out the objectives of the negotiation, and then come up with a strategy on
how to accomplish them. Make sure that you have the buy-in from your closest colleagues,
so that they can spread one uniform message with the same objectives in mind.
Also select team members you get along with. You don’t need to be friends, but
you need to be able to spend countless hours working together. Complex
negotiations take time, make sure your team gel and don’t get pre-occupied with
infighting.
Thirdly,
when you draw lines in the sand (or red lines like Mrs. May referred to) make
sure that it is out of a position of strength. More importantly make sure that
they are realistic. It didn’t help that Mrs. May chose targets that are only of
benefit to the UK, not the Euro area. She completely overestimated the UK’s position
of strength and didn’t analyze the alternative.
Forth, be
flexible. A trait all great leaders had was to be flexible. Changing your point
of view slightly doesn’t mean
that you are not fulfilling your objective. It also shows that you are willing
to compromise and work towards a solution. Thus your negotiations partners
knows you are working with them, rather than against them, leading to a
friendlier working environment which has been proven to yield better results. The
trick is to list as many objectives as possible, so that the negotiations don’t
get stuck on a few major elements, but that it is a fluid motion of give and
take. Theresa May is stubborn, uncompromising and inflexible. That caused her
to stumble in the negotiations and be defeated in parliament.
Fifth, make
sure that you have the numbers behind you. The conservatives had a small lead
in parliament when Article 50 was triggered, but the party was split between
strong Brexiteers and “Remainers”. Therefore, Theresa May would need the
support of some of the opposition party members of parliament. Instead of
reaching out to them, she decided to hold a snap election in which she lost the
majority in parliament. The results were a clear indication that the not even
the public approved of her work thus far. Yet she still didn’t reach out to the
main opposition parties to come up with a deal that would pass parliament.
Instead Mrs. May continued to thrash out a deal with the European Union, which
when it was finally ready to be voted on was defeated by the biggest margin
ever. It is simple math’s. If you don’t have a clear majority in parliament,
and you don’t have your whole party behind you, your deal will fail, unless it
is a combined effort of all the parties involved.
This also
leads me to the last point. If you enter negotiation, make sure that your
objectives are the objectives the majority of your team, in this case the British
parliament, approves of. Once you have that, it is time to start the clock and
negotiate with the opposing party.
The Brexit disaster
has been a tragedy that is still playing out. The parliament are making a fool
of themselves. The debates remind of a tired yawning soap opera that seems to
be never ending. The politicians seem to thrive in endless posturing and biggotting.
But I not sure if doing what is best for their community is a high priority.